What Insurance Adjusters Really Look For After an Accident
After a car accident, motorcycle accident, slip and fall, dog attack, or other injury-causing event, many people assume that insurance companies simply add up medical bills and make a settlement offer. In reality, insurance companies use a much more detailed process to evaluate personal injury claims.
Attorney Ken Doane spent years representing insurance companies and their policyholders before dedicating his practice to helping injury victims throughout Southern Indiana and Kentucky. This experience provides valuable insight into how insurance carriers investigate, evaluate, and defend personal injury claims.
Understanding how insurance companies view injury claims can help accident victims avoid common mistakes and better protect their rights.
Liability Comes First
Before evaluating injuries and damages, insurance companies determine who caused the accident.
Adjusters often review:
- Police reports
- Witness statements
- Photographs
- Surveillance footage
- Vehicle damage
- Accident scene evidence
- Recorded statements
Even in cases where fault appears clear, insurance companies frequently search for ways to shift some responsibility to the injured person.
Questions often include:
- Was the injured person distracted?
- Did they contribute to the accident?
- Did they fail to follow traffic laws?
- Were they paying attention?
The stronger the liability evidence, the more valuable the claim may become.
Medical Treatment Is Extremely Important
One of the first things an adjuster reviews is medical treatment.
Insurance companies often consider:
- How soon treatment began after the accident
- The type of medical treatment received
- Whether treatment recommendations were followed
- The duration of treatment
- Whether specialists were involved
- Whether surgery was required
Prompt and consistent treatment often strengthens a claim.
Gaps in Treatment Can Hurt a Claim
Insurance companies frequently focus on treatment gaps.
If an injured person waits weeks before seeking treatment or misses appointments, an adjuster may argue:
- The injury was not serious.
- The injury was unrelated to the accident.
- The person recovered quickly.
- The treatment was unnecessary.
This does not mean a claim is invalid, but treatment gaps often become an issue during negotiations.
Pre-Existing Conditions
Many accident victims have prior medical conditions.
Insurance companies commonly investigate:
- Prior injuries
- Prior accidents
- Prior surgeries
- Degenerative conditions
- Previous complaints involving the same body part
Adjusters often attempt to attribute symptoms to pre-existing conditions rather than the accident.
However, a negligent party may still be responsible when an accident aggravates a pre-existing condition.
Severity of Injury
Not all injuries are evaluated equally.
Insurance companies generally consider:
- Fractures
- Herniated discs
- Traumatic brain injuries
- Spinal cord injuries
- Nerve injuries
- Permanent impairment
- Surgical procedures
- Objective medical findings
Claims involving permanent injuries or surgery are often evaluated differently than claims involving short-term soft tissue injuries.
Lost Wages and Economic Losses
Insurance companies also evaluate financial losses.
Common considerations include:
- Time missed from work
- Reduced earning capacity
- Lost business income
- Future wage loss
- Employment records
Proper documentation is often critical when proving economic damages.
Pain and Suffering
Many injured individuals are surprised to learn that insurance companies evaluate pain and suffering separately from medical bills.
Factors that may affect pain and suffering damages include:
- Severity of injury
- Duration of symptoms
- Permanent limitations
- Scarring and disfigurement
- Impact on daily activities
- Impact on family relationships
Pain and suffering damages often become one of the most disputed aspects of an injury claim.
Insurance Policy Limits Matter
Even strong cases may be affected by available insurance coverage.
Insurance companies evaluate:
- Liability policy limits
- Umbrella coverage
- Commercial policies
- Uninsured motorist coverage
- Underinsured motorist coverage
Identifying all available sources of insurance coverage can significantly affect the value of a claim.
Social Media and Surveillance
Insurance companies increasingly investigate social media accounts.
Photographs, videos, comments, and activity posts may be reviewed in an attempt to challenge injury claims.
In some cases, insurance companies may also conduct surveillance.
Accident victims should be cautious about what they post online while a claim is pending.
Why Insurance Companies Make Low Initial Offers
Many insurance companies make early settlement offers before the full extent of injuries is known.
Common reasons include:
- Uncertainty regarding future treatment
- Lack of complete medical records
- Incomplete wage loss information
- Efforts to limit claim value
Accepting a settlement too early may prevent recovery for future damages that are not yet known.
How a Former Insurance Defense Attorney Can Help
Before representing injury victims, attorney Ken Doane spent years defending insurance companies and their insureds in Indiana, Kentucky, and Pennsylvania.
This experience provides insight into:
- How claims are evaluated
- How reserves are established
- How settlement authority is obtained
- How adjusters assess risk
- How defense attorneys prepare cases
Understanding the insurance company's perspective can be a significant advantage when pursuing compensation.
Contact Doane Law Office
If you have been injured in a car accident, motorcycle accident, slip and fall, dog attack, or other serious accident, understanding how insurance companies evaluate claims can help you make informed decisions.
Attorney Ken Doane has more than 25 years of experience representing injury victims throughout New Albany, Jeffersonville, Floyd County, Clark County, Southern Indiana, Louisville, and surrounding communities.
Contact Doane Law Office today for a free consultation. There is no attorney fee unless compensation is recovered on your behalf.
☎ Call Now: 812-590-2213
✉ Contact Us Online for a Free Consultation